{"allowContribute":false,"item":{"acquiredListingId":"6a220e7d968334c78d3c1ecd","aspectRatio":"16:9","createdAt":1789105965351,"deckSummary":"以 C. Thi Nguyen〈Value Capture〉為主軸的中文哲學討論簡報。從遊戲中清楚、可計數的價值感切入，說明「價值捕獲」不只是壞誘因，而是把判斷何者重要的過程外包給制度；依序討論組織、制度、平台與私生活案例，再提出主動求捕獲、兩項反駁、三個帶回去的問題與現場討論。定位為有張力、可引發辯論的分享，不把講述分鐘數寫入頁面。","id":"3ba9de908281b7d5c34c4c4b","isPublic":true,"itemType":"SLIDE_FOLDER","name":"Value Capture｜當我們把「什麼才重要」外包出去","parents":{"slide":1789102888239},"sourceItemId":"0f6485f7b182809737820a86","theme":"{\"bg\":\"#10131C\",\"text\":\"#F5F1E8\",\"accent\":\"#DFFF4F\",\"fontDisplay\":\"'Noto Serif TC', serif\",\"fontBody\":\"'Noto Sans TC', sans-serif\"}","updatedAt":1789801535299,"updatedBy":{"userId":"2e84aab5-d898-4d2f-8d2a-","userName":"許育慈"},"version":2},"ownerName":"許育慈","subtree":[{"acquiredListingId":"6a220e7d968334c78d3c1ecd","aspectRatio":"16:9","createdAt":1789105965351,"deckSummary":"以 C. Thi Nguyen〈Value Capture〉為主軸的中文哲學討論簡報。從遊戲中清楚、可計數的價值感切入，說明「價值捕獲」不只是壞誘因，而是把判斷何者重要的過程外包給制度；依序討論組織、制度、平台與私生活案例，再提出主動求捕獲、兩項反駁、三個帶回去的問題與現場討論。定位為有張力、可引發辯論的分享，不把講述分鐘數寫入頁面。","id":"3ba9de908281b7d5c34c4c4b","isPublic":true,"itemType":"SLIDE_FOLDER","name":"Value Capture｜當我們把「什麼才重要」外包出去","parents":{"slide":1789102888239},"sourceItemId":"0f6485f7b182809737820a86","theme":"{\"bg\":\"#10131C\",\"text\":\"#F5F1E8\",\"accent\":\"#DFFF4F\",\"fontDisplay\":\"'Noto Serif TC', serif\",\"fontBody\":\"'Noto Sans TC', sans-serif\"}","updatedAt":1789801535299,"updatedBy":{"userId":"2e84aab5-d898-4d2f-8d2a-","userName":"許育慈"},"version":2},{"content":"export default function Slide() { return (\u003cdiv style={{width:'100%',height:'100%',boxSizing:'border-box',padding:125,display:'flex',flexDirection:'column',justifyContent:'center',background:'var(--osd-bg)',color:'var(--osd-text)',fontFamily:'var(--osd-font-body)'}}\u003e\u003ch1 style={{fontFamily:'var(--osd-font-display)',fontSize:78,lineHeight:1.15,margin:'0 0 85px'}}\u003e捕獲不是一瞬間；它是一條很順的捷徑\u003c/h1\u003e\u003cdiv style={{display:'flex',alignItems:'center',gap:15}}\u003e\u003cdiv style={{width:365,minHeight:242,padding:34,boxSizing:'border-box',borderRadius:'var(--osd-radius)',background:'rgba(255,255,255,.07)',fontSize:34,lineHeight:1.35}}\u003e我原本在意的事\u003cbr/\u003e\u003cstrong style={{fontSize:46}}\u003e豐富、模糊、未定型\u003c/strong\u003e\u003c/div\u003e\u003cdiv style={{fontSize:58,color:'var(--osd-accent)'}}\u003e→\u003c/div\u003e\u003cdiv style={{width:365,minHeight:242,padding:34,boxSizing:'border-box',borderRadius:'var(--osd-radius)',background:'rgba(255,255,255,.07)',fontSize:34,lineHeight:1.35}}\u003e制度替它做出代理\u003cbr/\u003e\u003cstrong style={{fontSize:46}}\u003e分數、排名、KPI\u003c/strong\u003e\u003c/div\u003e\u003cdiv style={{fontSize:58,color:'var(--osd-accent)'}}\u003e→\u003c/div\u003e\u003cdiv style={{width:365,minHeight:242,padding:34,boxSizing:'border-box',borderRadius:'var(--osd-radius)',background:'#FFFFFF',color:'#101010',fontSize:34,lineHeight:1.35}}\u003e代理變成我追逐的目標\u003cbr/\u003e\u003cstrong style={{fontSize:46}}\u003e分數開始定義價值\u003c/strong\u003e\u003c/div\u003e\u003c/div\u003e\u003cp style={{fontSize:34,opacity:.75,margin:'65px 0 0',lineHeight:1.45}}\u003e關鍵不是代理本身存在，而是我們何時不再把它當成代理。\u003c/p\u003e\u003c/div\u003e); }","createdAt":1789105965351,"id":"9b2327ab890752f5b9889459","itemType":"SLIDE","name":"05｜從價值到分數","parents":{"3ba9de908281b7d5c34c4c4b":1789103170112},"sourceItemId":"18564519318c0852610ac5b9","speakerNotes":"用「代理」這個詞避免粗暴地說 KPI 或量化都是壞的。每個指標都必然遺漏東西；危險是遺漏被忘掉了。","updatedAt":1789105965351,"updatedBy":{"userId":"2e84aab5-d898-4d2f-8d2a-","userName":"許育慈"},"version":1},{"content":"export default function Slide() { return (\u003cdiv style={{width:'100%',height:'100%',boxSizing:'border-box',padding:135,display:'flex',flexDirection:'column',justifyContent:'space-between',background:'var(--osd-bg)',color:'var(--osd-text)',fontFamily:'var(--osd-font-body)'}}\u003e\u003cdiv style={{fontSize:28,color:'var(--osd-accent)',fontWeight:700,letterSpacing:4}}\u003eVALUE CAPTURE\u003c/div\u003e\u003cdiv\u003e\u003ch1 style={{fontFamily:'var(--osd-font-display)',fontSize:88,lineHeight:1.12,margin:0,maxWidth:1550}}\u003e問題從來不是\u003cbr/\u003e\u003cspan style={{color:'var(--osd-accent)'}}\u003e有沒有分數。\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/h1\u003e\u003cp style={{fontSize:53,lineHeight:1.35,margin:'35px 0 0',maxWidth:1400}}\u003e而是我們還記不記得：\u003cbr/\u003e分數只是替某種價值服務，不是價值本身。\u003c/p\u003e\u003c/div\u003e\u003cdiv style={{fontSize:28,opacity:.6,lineHeight:1.5}}\u003e主要文本：C. Thi Nguyen, “Value Capture”\u003cbr/\u003e延伸閱讀：Nguyen, \u003cem\u003eThe Score\u003c/em\u003e（2025）\u003c/div\u003e\u003c/div\u003e); }","createdAt":1789105965351,"id":"c02f0cd42238b8daf3515281","itemType":"SLIDE","name":"18｜結語：不是反對分數","parents":{"3ba9de908281b7d5c34c4c4b":1789103171412},"sourceItemId":"1cafb2ed7d931cad9fa74d16","speakerNotes":"回扣第一頁：那些 app 不是敵人，但要重新問：究竟是我在使用分數，還是分數在使用我？","updatedAt":1789105965351,"updatedBy":{"userId":"2e84aab5-d898-4d2f-8d2a-","userName":"許育慈"},"version":1},{"content":"export default function Slide() { return (\u003cdiv style={{width:'100%',height:'100%',boxSizing:'border-box',padding:'110px 130px',display:'flex',flexDirection:'column',justifyContent:'center',background:'var(--osd-bg)',color:'var(--osd-text)',fontFamily:'var(--osd-font-body)'}}\u003e\u003ch1 style={{fontFamily:'var(--osd-font-display)',fontSize:80,lineHeight:1.15,margin:0}}\u003e這不只是「誘因設計不良」\u003c/h1\u003e\u003cdiv style={{display:'flex',gap:45,marginTop:75}}\u003e\u003cdiv style={{flex:1,padding:46,borderRadius:'var(--osd-radius)',background:'rgba(255,255,255,.06)'}}\u003e\u003cdiv style={{fontSize:27,opacity:.65,letterSpacing:2}}\u003e一般的批評\u003c/div\u003e\u003ch2 style={{fontFamily:'var(--osd-font-display)',fontSize:52,lineHeight:1.2,margin:'25px 0'}}\u003e指標引導了\u003cbr/\u003e錯誤行為\u003c/h2\u003e\u003cp style={{fontSize:30,lineHeight:1.45,opacity:.76}}\u003e修正獎勵機制、換一個 KPI，問題似乎就能解決。\u003c/p\u003e\u003c/div\u003e\u003cdiv style={{flex:1,padding:46,borderRadius:'var(--osd-radius)',background:'#FFFFFF',color:'#111'}}\u003e\u003cdiv style={{fontSize:27,opacity:.72,letterSpacing:2}}\u003eNguyen 更深的批評\u003c/div\u003e\u003ch2 style={{fontFamily:'var(--osd-font-display)',fontSize:52,lineHeight:1.2,margin:'25px 0'}}\u003e我們失去退一步問：\u003cbr/\u003e這真的重要嗎？\u003c/h2\u003e\u003cp style={{fontSize:30,lineHeight:1.45,opacity:.82}}\u003e損失的是反思與自我培養價值的能力，不只是行為被帶偏。\u003c/p\u003e\u003c/div\u003e\u003c/div\u003e\u003c/div\u003e); }","createdAt":1789105965351,"id":"66566ac5edf63eef806bc04e","itemType":"SLIDE","name":"06｜不只是誘因壞了","parents":{"3ba9de908281b7d5c34c4c4b":1789103170212},"sourceItemId":"3355a1cd9c7104d025b8fd04","speakerNotes":"這是全場的重要轉折。不要把論點講成「指標錯了，所以換指標」。Nguyen 關切的是人對價值的主體性。","updatedAt":1789105965351,"updatedBy":{"userId":"2e84aab5-d898-4d2f-8d2a-","userName":"許育慈"},"version":1},{"content":"export default function Slide() { return (\u003cdiv style={{width:'100%',height:'100%',boxSizing:'border-box',padding:120,display:'flex',flexDirection:'column',justifyContent:'center',background:'var(--osd-bg)',color:'var(--osd-text)',fontFamily:'var(--osd-font-body)'}}\u003e\u003cdiv style={{fontSize:28,color:'var(--osd-accent)',fontWeight:700,letterSpacing:3,marginBottom:24}}\u003e討論\u003c/div\u003e\u003ch1 style={{fontFamily:'var(--osd-font-display)',fontSize:75,lineHeight:1.15,margin:'0 0 50px'}}\u003e哪一個分數，正在替你決定重要性？\u003c/h1\u003e\u003cdiv style={{display:'grid',gridTemplateColumns:'1fr 1fr',gap:22}}\u003e\u003cdiv style={{padding:30,background:'rgba(255,255,255,.06)',fontSize:30,lineHeight:1.4,borderRadius:'var(--osd-radius)'}}\u003e你工作裡哪個 KPI 最接近「獎勵 A、期待 B」？\u003c/div\u003e\u003cdiv style={{padding:30,background:'rgba(255,255,255,.06)',fontSize:30,lineHeight:1.4,borderRadius:'var(--osd-radius)'}}\u003e你曾主動安裝哪個「求捕獲」的 app？後來呢？\u003c/div\u003e\u003cdiv style={{padding:30,background:'rgba(255,255,255,.06)',fontSize:30,lineHeight:1.4,borderRadius:'var(--osd-radius)'}}\u003e有沒有哪件原本喜歡的事，被計分後就不好玩了？\u003c/div\u003e\u003cdiv style={{padding:30,background:'rgba(255,255,255,.06)',fontSize:30,lineHeight:1.4,borderRadius:'var(--osd-radius)'}}\u003e清楚指標大幅降低溝通成本：這個好處要不要？\u003c/div\u003e\u003c/div\u003e\u003c/div\u003e); }","createdAt":1789105965351,"id":"e365751092e7a0c85889590b","itemType":"SLIDE","name":"17｜討論：把案例帶進來","parents":{"3ba9de908281b7d5c34c4c4b":1789103171312},"sourceItemId":"36065623bdc8daf9a97d0724","speakerNotes":"若時間有限，選一題深聊即可。可以請一位支持指標的人先發言，避免討論變成互相認同。","updatedAt":1789105965351,"updatedBy":{"userId":"2e84aab5-d898-4d2f-8d2a-","userName":"許育慈"},"version":1},{"content":"export default function Slide() { return (\u003cdiv style={{width:'100%',height:'100%',boxSizing:'border-box',padding:125,background:'var(--osd-bg)',color:'var(--osd-text)',fontFamily:'var(--osd-font-body)'}}\u003e\u003cdiv style={{fontSize:27,color:'var(--osd-accent)',fontWeight:700,letterSpacing:3,marginBottom:18}}\u003e案例地圖\u003c/div\u003e\u003ch1 style={{fontFamily:'var(--osd-font-display)',fontSize:76,lineHeight:1.14,margin:'0 0 60px'}}\u003e價值捕獲，從制度滲入日常\u003c/h1\u003e\u003cdiv style={{display:'grid',gridTemplateColumns:'1fr 1fr',gap:24}}\u003e\u003cdiv style={{padding:'31px 38px',borderLeft:'7px solid var(--osd-accent)',background:'rgba(255,255,255,.05)'}}\u003e\u003cstrong style={{fontSize:34}}\u003e01　組織層\u003c/strong\u003e\u003cspan style={{fontSize:27,opacity:.7}}\u003e　獎勵什麼，就學會追什麼\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/div\u003e\u003cdiv style={{padding:'31px 38px',borderLeft:'7px solid var(--osd-accent)',background:'rgba(255,255,255,.05)'}}\u003e\u003cstrong style={{fontSize:34}}\u003e02　制度層\u003c/strong\u003e\u003cspan style={{fontSize:27,opacity:.7}}\u003e　計分遮蔽了運動與學習\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/div\u003e\u003cdiv style={{padding:'31px 38px',borderLeft:'7px solid var(--osd-accent)',background:'rgba(255,255,255,.05)'}}\u003e\u003cstrong style={{fontSize:34}}\u003e03　平台層\u003c/strong\u003e\u003cspan style={{fontSize:27,opacity:.7}}\u003e　缺乏退出與替代的選擇\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/div\u003e\u003cdiv style={{padding:'31px 38px',borderLeft:'7px solid var(--osd-accent)',background:'rgba(255,255,255,.05)'}}\u003e\u003cstrong style={{fontSize:34}}\u003e04　私生活層\u003c/strong\u003e\u003cspan style={{fontSize:27,opacity:.7}}\u003e　休閒也有了考核與罪惡感\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/div\u003e\u003c/div\u003e\u003c/div\u003e); }","createdAt":1789105965351,"id":"ef697f0aa76e3dd4cd02ce69","itemType":"SLIDE","name":"07｜四層案例：由外而內","parents":{"3ba9de908281b7d5c34c4c4b":1789103170312},"sourceItemId":"39bf8a06f0987aa60991883a","speakerNotes":"接下來四頁由外而內。讓觀眾看見這不是單一 app 的怪現象，而是組織、制度與生活共享的結構。","updatedAt":1789105965351,"updatedBy":{"userId":"2e84aab5-d898-4d2f-8d2a-","userName":"許育慈"},"version":1},{"content":"export default function Slide() { return (\u003cdiv style={{width:'100%',height:'100%',boxSizing:'border-box',padding:115,display:'flex',flexDirection:'column',justifyContent:'center',background:'var(--osd-bg)',color:'var(--osd-text)',fontFamily:'var(--osd-font-body)'}}\u003e\u003cdiv style={{fontSize:27,color:'var(--osd-accent)',fontWeight:700,letterSpacing:3,marginBottom:18}}\u003e04｜私生活層\u003c/div\u003e\u003ch1 style={{fontFamily:'var(--osd-font-display)',fontSize:76,lineHeight:1.15,margin:0}}\u003e當休閒也有績效，\u003cbr/\u003e它就開始像另一份工作。\u003c/h1\u003e\u003cdiv style={{display:'flex',gap:18,marginTop:62}}\u003e\u003cdiv style={{flex:1,padding:28,background:'rgba(255,255,255,.06)',borderRadius:'var(--osd-radius)'}}\u003e\u003cdiv style={{fontSize:42}}\u003e🏃\u003c/div\u003e\u003cdiv style={{fontSize:31,fontWeight:700,marginTop:13}}\u003e健身\u003c/div\u003e\u003cdiv style={{fontSize:26,lineHeight:1.35,opacity:.7}}\u003e晨跑變排行榜\u003c/div\u003e\u003c/div\u003e\u003cdiv style={{flex:1,padding:28,background:'rgba(255,255,255,.06)',borderRadius:'var(--osd-radius)'}}\u003e\u003cdiv style={{fontSize:42}}\u003e◌\u003c/div\u003e\u003cdiv style={{fontSize:31,fontWeight:700,marginTop:13}}\u003e冥想\u003c/div\u003e\u003cdiv style={{fontSize:26,lineHeight:1.35,opacity:.7}}\u003e安靜變連續天數\u003c/div\u003e\u003c/div\u003e\u003cdiv style={{flex:1,padding:28,background:'rgba(255,255,255,.06)',borderRadius:'var(--osd-radius)'}}\u003e\u003cdiv style={{fontSize:42}}\u003eA↗\u003c/div\u003e\u003cdiv style={{fontSize:31,fontWeight:700,marginTop:13}}\u003e語言\u003c/div\u003e\u003cdiv style={{fontSize:26,lineHeight:1.35,opacity:.7}}\u003e好奇心變徽章\u003c/div\u003e\u003c/div\u003e\u003cdiv style={{flex:1,padding:28,background:'rgba(255,255,255,.06)',borderRadius:'var(--osd-radius)'}}\u003e\u003cdiv style={{fontSize:42}}\u003e✎\u003c/div\u003e\u003cdiv style={{fontSize:31,fontWeight:700,marginTop:13}}\u003e日記\u003c/div\u003e\u003cdiv style={{fontSize:26,lineHeight:1.35,opacity:.7}}\u003e書寫變一致性分數\u003c/div\u003e\u003c/div\u003e\u003c/div\u003e\u003cp style={{fontSize:35,lineHeight:1.4,margin:'62px 0 0',color:'var(--osd-accent)',fontWeight:700}}\u003e本來滋養人的事，也可能開始帶著指標與罪惡感。\u003c/p\u003e\u003c/div\u003e); }","createdAt":1789105965351,"id":"23d6341925a57d6f5a860955","itemType":"SLIDE","name":"11｜私生活：休閒成了第三輪班","parents":{"3ba9de908281b7d5c34c4c4b":1789103170712},"sourceItemId":"54196a256fa54bec09bcdcb3","speakerNotes":"可請觀眾在心中對照自己使用的 app。語氣要保留：這些工具也可能幫助人開始或持續做事，爭點在於它是否吞掉了原本的理由。","updatedAt":1789105965351,"updatedBy":{"userId":"2e84aab5-d898-4d2f-8d2a-","userName":"許育慈"},"version":1},{"content":"export default function Slide() { return (\u003cdiv style={{width:'100%',height:'100%',boxSizing:'border-box',padding:135,display:'flex',flexDirection:'column',justifyContent:'center',background:'var(--osd-bg)',color:'var(--osd-text)',fontFamily:'var(--osd-font-body)'}}\u003e\u003cdiv style={{fontSize:27,color:'var(--osd-accent)',fontWeight:700,letterSpacing:3,marginBottom:24}}\u003e一個小故事\u003c/div\u003e\u003ch1 style={{fontFamily:'var(--osd-font-display)',fontSize:73,lineHeight:1.22,margin:0,maxWidth:1550}}\u003e沒有精確份量與時間的食譜，\u003cbr/\u003e不一定表示落後。\u003c/h1\u003e\u003cdiv style={{marginTop:66,padding:'40px 48px',borderLeft:'8px solid var(--osd-accent)',fontSize:37,lineHeight:1.55,maxWidth:1480,background:'rgba(255,255,255,.04)'}}\u003eNguyen 年輕時曾嘲笑母親的食譜不精確；後來才理解：那不是缺乏標準，而是蘊含了更成熟的判斷——看、聞、摸、調整，知道何時才算對。\u003c/div\u003e\u003cp style={{fontSize:34,marginTop:55,opacity:.72}}\u003e有些價值不是尚未量化，而是\u003cspan style={{color:'var(--osd-accent)',fontWeight:700}}\u003e不該被一次量盡\u003c/span\u003e。\u003c/p\u003e\u003c/div\u003e); }","createdAt":1789105965351,"id":"2badf0cde684c86ea8e84e47","itemType":"SLIDE","name":"12｜母親的食譜","parents":{"3ba9de908281b7d5c34c4c4b":1789103170812},"sourceItemId":"646fbc3112238d27d7f5b917","speakerNotes":"用故事讓抽象概念落地。強調「反對精確」不是重點；重點是成熟實作中有一部分判斷，無法由清單替代。","updatedAt":1789105965351,"updatedBy":{"userId":"2e84aab5-d898-4d2f-8d2a-","userName":"許育慈"},"version":1},{"content":"export default function Slide() { return (\u003cdiv style={{width:'100%',height:'100%',boxSizing:'border-box',padding:130,display:'flex',flexDirection:'column',justifyContent:'center',background:'var(--osd-bg)',color:'var(--osd-text)',fontFamily:'var(--osd-font-body)'}}\u003e\u003cdiv style={{fontSize:30,color:'var(--osd-accent)',fontWeight:700,letterSpacing:3,marginBottom:35}}\u003e現場提問\u003c/div\u003e\u003ch1 style={{fontFamily:'var(--osd-font-display)',fontSize:82,lineHeight:1.2,margin:0,maxWidth:1500}}\u003e你手機裡，有幾個 app 正在替你記分數、徽章，或連續天數？\u003c/h1\u003e\u003cdiv style={{marginTop:80,display:'flex',gap:25,alignItems:'center'}}\u003e\u003cdiv style={{fontSize:170,color:'var(--osd-accent)',fontFamily:'var(--osd-font-display)',lineHeight:1}}\u003e?\u003c/div\u003e\u003cp style={{fontSize:38,lineHeight:1.5,maxWidth:1040,margin:0,opacity:.82}}\u003e請大家舉手數一數。\u003cbr/\u003e這個數字，就是今天整場的伏筆。\u003c/p\u003e\u003c/div\u003e\u003c/div\u003e); }","createdAt":1789105965351,"id":"71d4eb15f97b2e619c4a8716","itemType":"SLIDE","name":"02｜先數一數","parents":{"3ba9de908281b7d5c34c4c4b":1789103169812},"sourceItemId":"70d543c2b8ef61a115e51100","speakerNotes":"邀請大家真的停一下、心裡數一數：運動、學習、睡眠、冥想、社群、工作管理。不要立刻批判；先讓大家意識到計分已經無所不在。","updatedAt":1789105965351,"updatedBy":{"userId":"2e84aab5-d898-4d2f-8d2a-","userName":"許育慈"},"version":1},{"content":"export default function Slide() { return (\u003cdiv style={{width:'100%',height:'100%',boxSizing:'border-box',padding:130,display:'flex',flexDirection:'column',justifyContent:'center',background:'var(--osd-bg)',color:'var(--osd-text)',fontFamily:'var(--osd-font-body)'}}\u003e\u003cdiv style={{fontSize:28,color:'var(--osd-accent)',letterSpacing:3,fontWeight:700,marginBottom:28}}\u003e核心主張\u003c/div\u003e\u003ch1 style={{fontFamily:'var(--osd-font-display)',fontSize:86,lineHeight:1.18,margin:0,maxWidth:1540}}\u003e最危險的不一定是壞指標，\u003cbr/\u003e而是它讓我們\u003cspan style={{color:'var(--osd-accent)'}}\u003e忘記自己能判斷\u003c/span\u003e。\u003c/h1\u003e\u003cdiv style={{marginTop:75,borderLeft:'8px solid var(--osd-accent)',paddingLeft:34,fontSize:39,lineHeight:1.45,opacity:.86,maxWidth:1360}}\u003eValue capture：一套外部制度把原本細緻、仍在形成的價值，壓縮成簡化版本；而那個版本反過來主導了我們的行動與注意力。\u003c/div\u003e\u003c/div\u003e); }","createdAt":1789105965351,"id":"316b86ba15f2ff75e0d491c9","itemType":"SLIDE","name":"03｜今天的主張","parents":{"3ba9de908281b7d5c34c4c4b":1789103169912},"sourceItemId":"83309d403e442a4f8df95af0","speakerNotes":"這頁先給全場一條可記住的論點。重點不是「數字有害」，而是數字從工具變成我們無法退後檢視的判準。","updatedAt":1789105965351,"updatedBy":{"userId":"2e84aab5-d898-4d2f-8d2a-","userName":"許育慈"},"version":1},{"content":"export default function Slide() { return (\u003cdiv style={{width:'100%',height:'100%',boxSizing:'border-box',padding:125,background:'var(--osd-bg)',color:'var(--osd-text)',fontFamily:'var(--osd-font-body)'}}\u003e\u003ch1 style={{fontFamily:'var(--osd-font-display)',fontSize:77,lineHeight:1.15,margin:'0 0 68px'}}\u003e我們交換到什麼？又交出了什麼？\u003c/h1\u003e\u003cdiv style={{display:'flex',gap:36}}\u003e\u003cdiv style={{flex:1,padding:48,borderRadius:'var(--osd-radius)',background:'rgba(255,255,255,.06)'}}\u003e\u003cdiv style={{fontSize:30,color:'var(--osd-accent)',letterSpacing:3,fontWeight:700}}\u003e紅利\u003c/div\u003e\u003cul style={{fontSize:37,lineHeight:1.68,margin:'26px 0 0',paddingLeft:40}}\u003e\u003cli\u003e價值變得清楚\u003c/li\u003e\u003cli\u003e行動變得一致\u003c/li\u003e\u003cli\u003e容易共享與溝通\u003c/li\u003e\u003cli\u003e不必反覆解釋自己\u003c/li\u003e\u003c/ul\u003e\u003c/div\u003e\u003cdiv style={{flex:1,padding:48,borderRadius:'var(--osd-radius)',background:'#FFFFFF',color:'#121212'}}\u003e\u003cdiv style={{fontSize:30,letterSpacing:3,fontWeight:700,opacity:.75}}\u003e代價\u003c/div\u003e\u003cul style={{fontSize:37,lineHeight:1.68,margin:'26px 0 0',paddingLeft:40}}\u003e\u003cli\u003e外部制度穩定了我的價值\u003c/li\u003e\u003cli\u003e複雜的理由被壓縮\u003c/li\u003e\u003cli\u003e反思的肌肉逐漸萎縮\u003c/li\u003e\u003cli\u003e離開分數會感到失重\u003c/li\u003e\u003c/ul\u003e\u003c/div\u003e\u003c/div\u003e\u003c/div\u003e); }","createdAt":1789105965351,"id":"6afd52d1fdef64b4dfb9c93c","itemType":"SLIDE","name":"14｜捕獲的紅利與代價","parents":{"3ba9de908281b7d5c34c4c4b":1789103171012},"sourceItemId":"873dca7e2b169efd46f07aee","speakerNotes":"這頁可防止簡化成道德說教。每一個捕獲都提供好處，否則人不會主動選擇它；理論真正有力的地方就是同時看見兩邊。","updatedAt":1789105965351,"updatedBy":{"userId":"2e84aab5-d898-4d2f-8d2a-","userName":"許育慈"},"version":1},{"content":"export default function Slide() { return (\u003cdiv style={{width:'100%',height:'100%',boxSizing:'border-box',padding:'100px 125px',background:'var(--osd-bg)',color:'var(--osd-text)',fontFamily:'var(--osd-font-body)'}}\u003e\u003ch1 style={{fontFamily:'var(--osd-font-display)',fontSize:73,margin:'0 0 66px',lineHeight:1.12}}\u003e遊戲令人舒服，因為價值很清楚\u003c/h1\u003e\u003cdiv style={{display:'flex',gap:38,height:650}}\u003e\u003cdiv style={{flex:1,padding:55,border:'2px solid var(--osd-accent)',borderRadius:'var(--osd-radius)',background:'rgba(255,255,255,.03)'}}\u003e\u003cdiv style={{fontSize:31,color:'var(--osd-accent)',fontWeight:700,letterSpacing:3}}\u003e遊戲裡的價值\u003c/div\u003e\u003cdiv style={{fontFamily:'var(--osd-font-display)',fontSize:65,marginTop:45,lineHeight:1.45}}\u003e單一\u003cbr/\u003e可計數\u003cbr/\u003e有終點\u003c/div\u003e\u003cp style={{fontSize:31,lineHeight:1.45,opacity:.72}}\u003e目標明確、成就可排名；你知道自己在做什麼，也知道何時算成功。\u003c/p\u003e\u003c/div\u003e\u003cdiv style={{flex:1,padding:55,border:'2px solid rgba(255,255,255,.25)',borderRadius:'var(--osd-radius)'}}\u003e\u003cdiv style={{fontSize:31,opacity:.7,fontWeight:700,letterSpacing:3}}\u003e現實裡的價值\u003c/div\u003e\u003cdiv style={{fontFamily:'var(--osd-font-display)',fontSize:65,marginTop:45,lineHeight:1.45}}\u003e細緻\u003cbr/\u003e多重\u003cbr/\u003e互相衝突\u003c/div\u003e\u003cp style={{fontSize:31,lineHeight:1.45,opacity:.72}}\u003e好的工作、親密關係、健康與人生，常常沒有唯一計分板，更沒有標準終局。\u003c/p\u003e\u003c/div\u003e\u003c/div\u003e\u003c/div\u003e); }","createdAt":1789105965351,"id":"308cfc75f1133d18f6884c7f","itemType":"SLIDE","name":"04｜遊戲與現實的價值","parents":{"3ba9de908281b7d5c34c4c4b":1789103170012},"sourceItemId":"9f4a6421912a6092e7a16cdc","speakerNotes":"遊戲不是反面教材。Nguyen 的洞見正是：清楚的目標、分數與回饋非常迷人，也非常有用；因此它才有能力改造我們。","updatedAt":1789105965351,"updatedBy":{"userId":"2e84aab5-d898-4d2f-8d2a-","userName":"許育慈"},"version":1},{"content":"export default function Slide() { return (\u003cdiv style={{width:'100%',height:'100%',boxSizing:'border-box',padding:125,display:'flex',flexDirection:'column',justifyContent:'center',background:'var(--osd-bg)',color:'var(--osd-text)',fontFamily:'var(--osd-font-body)'}}\u003e\u003cdiv style={{fontSize:27,color:'var(--osd-accent)',fontWeight:700,letterSpacing:3,marginBottom:20}}\u003e01｜組織層　Steven Kerr 的提醒\u003c/div\u003e\u003ch1 style={{fontFamily:'var(--osd-font-display)',fontSize:75,lineHeight:1.15,margin:0,maxWidth:1500}}\u003e組織常常獎勵它聲稱想抑制的行為，卻沒有獎勵它真正想要的行為。\u003c/h1\u003e\u003cdiv style={{marginTop:70,display:'flex',gap:32}}\u003e\u003cdiv style={{flex:1,padding:40,background:'rgba(255,255,255,.06)',borderRadius:'var(--osd-radius)'}}\u003e\u003cdiv style={{fontSize:27,opacity:.65}}\u003e看得見、容易計算\u003c/div\u003e\u003cdiv style={{fontSize:46,marginTop:17,fontWeight:700,color:'var(--osd-accent)'}}\u003e案件量\u003cbr/\u003e工時\u003cbr/\u003e短期業績\u003c/div\u003e\u003c/div\u003e\u003cdiv style={{fontSize:60,color:'var(--osd-accent)',alignSelf:'center'}}\u003e≠\u003c/div\u003e\u003cdiv style={{flex:1,padding:40,background:'rgba(255,255,255,.06)',borderRadius:'var(--osd-radius)'}}\u003e\u003cdiv style={{fontSize:27,opacity:.65}}\u003e其實想要、卻難量化\u003c/div\u003e\u003cdiv style={{fontSize:46,marginTop:17,fontWeight:700}}\u003e好判斷\u003cbr/\u003e好協作\u003cbr/\u003e長期信任\u003c/div\u003e\u003c/div\u003e\u003c/div\u003e\u003c/div\u003e); }","createdAt":1789105965351,"id":"1a6cbb67c9ee872e1f438487","itemType":"SLIDE","name":"08｜組織層：獎勵 A，期待 B","parents":{"3ba9de908281b7d5c34c4c4b":1789103170412},"sourceItemId":"ab30838255567635be071055","speakerNotes":"引用 Kerr 的經典格言，但不要把它當成只有管理技術的問題。當整個人開始把量化代理視為成功本身，捕獲就發生了。","updatedAt":1789105965351,"updatedBy":{"userId":"2e84aab5-d898-4d2f-8d2a-","userName":"許育慈"},"version":1},{"content":"export default function Slide() { return (\u003cdiv style={{width:'100%',height:'100%',boxSizing:'border-box',padding:125,background:'var(--osd-bg)',color:'var(--osd-text)',fontFamily:'var(--osd-font-body)'}}\u003e\u003cdiv style={{fontSize:27,color:'var(--osd-accent)',fontWeight:700,letterSpacing:3,marginBottom:20}}\u003e03｜平台層\u003c/div\u003e\u003ch1 style={{fontFamily:'var(--osd-font-display)',fontSize:76,lineHeight:1.15,margin:0}}\u003e遊戲與平台的關鍵差別：\u003cspan style={{color:'var(--osd-accent)'}}\u003e你能否退出？\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/h1\u003e\u003cdiv style={{display:'flex',gap:35,marginTop:68}}\u003e\u003cdiv style={{flex:1,padding:44,borderRadius:'var(--osd-radius)',background:'rgba(255,255,255,.06)'}}\u003e\u003cdiv style={{fontSize:32,color:'var(--osd-accent)',fontWeight:700}}\u003e遊戲\u003c/div\u003e\u003cp style={{fontSize:34,lineHeight:1.5,marginBottom:0}}\u003e可從多種遊戲中選擇；玩過後，也能離開並反省：它到底好不好玩？\u003c/p\u003e\u003c/div\u003e\u003cdiv style={{flex:1,padding:44,borderRadius:'var(--osd-radius)',background:'#FFFFFF',color:'#111'}}\u003e\u003cdiv style={{fontSize:32,fontWeight:700}}\u003e社群平台\u003c/div\u003e\u003cp style={{fontSize:34,lineHeight:1.5,marginBottom:0}}\u003e替代方案稀少，社交關係被綁在裡面；按讚、追蹤與排名很難被「暫時擱在一邊」。\u003c/p\u003e\u003c/div\u003e\u003c/div\u003e\u003cp style={{fontSize:32,lineHeight:1.45,margin:'50px 0 0',opacity:.74}}\u003e自主不只是在一開始說「我同意」，還包括持續能離開、比較與重新判斷。\u003c/p\u003e\u003c/div\u003e); }","createdAt":1789105965351,"id":"51a59f4242a4ea01d53fc59d","itemType":"SLIDE","name":"10｜平台層：退出權的差別","parents":{"3ba9de908281b7d5c34c4c4b":1789103170612},"sourceItemId":"b88fd60587990fe41aa9a0d5","speakerNotes":"說清楚：Nguyen 並不是說遊戲必然健康、平台必然邪惡；問題是制度多大程度保留反思與退出的空間。","updatedAt":1789105965351,"updatedBy":{"userId":"2e84aab5-d898-4d2f-8d2a-","userName":"許育慈"},"version":1},{"content":"export default function Slide() { return (\u003cdiv style={{width:'100%',height:'100%',boxSizing:'border-box',padding:'110px 130px',display:'flex',flexDirection:'column',justifyContent:'space-between',background:'var(--osd-bg)',color:'var(--osd-text)',fontFamily:'var(--osd-font-body)'}}\u003e\u003cdiv style={{display:'flex',alignItems:'center',gap:18,color:'var(--osd-accent)',fontSize:28,letterSpacing:4,fontWeight:700}}\u003e\u003cspan style={{width:54,height:4,background:'var(--osd-accent)',display:'inline-block'}}/\u003eC. THI NGUYEN\u003c/div\u003e\u003cdiv\u003e\u003ch1 style={{margin:0,fontFamily:'var(--osd-font-display)',fontSize:'var(--osd-size-hero)',lineHeight:1.08,letterSpacing:-3}}\u003eValue Capture\u003c/h1\u003e\u003cp style={{margin:'24px 0 0',fontSize:55,lineHeight:1.3,color:'var(--osd-accent)',fontWeight:700}}\u003e當我們把「什麼才重要」\u003cbr/\u003e外包出去\u003c/p\u003e\u003c/div\u003e\u003cp style={{margin:0,fontSize:27,opacity:.62}}\u003e從遊戲、KPI、平台到自我量化：誰正在替我們決定價值？\u003c/p\u003e\u003c/div\u003e); }","createdAt":1789105965351,"id":"924be4bcab065d06fcfe6ec7","itemType":"SLIDE","name":"01｜封面","parents":{"3ba9de908281b7d5c34c4c4b":1789103169712},"sourceItemId":"c50469d1dbedcf8910414e63","speakerNotes":"開場先不要急著定義。讓觀眾先把問題放在自己身上：我們每天看見的數字，到底是在描述生活，還是在安排生活？","updatedAt":1789105965351,"updatedBy":{"userId":"2e84aab5-d898-4d2f-8d2a-","userName":"許育慈"},"version":1},{"content":"export default function Slide() { return (\u003cdiv style={{width:'100%',height:'100%',boxSizing:'border-box',padding:125,display:'flex',flexDirection:'column',justifyContent:'center',background:'var(--osd-bg)',color:'var(--osd-text)',fontFamily:'var(--osd-font-body)'}}\u003e\u003cdiv style={{fontSize:27,color:'var(--osd-accent)',fontWeight:700,letterSpacing:3,marginBottom:22}}\u003e別急著同意 Nguyen\u003c/div\u003e\u003ch1 style={{fontFamily:'var(--osd-font-display)',fontSize:76,lineHeight:1.15,margin:0}}\u003e兩個反駁，留給現場吵\u003c/h1\u003e\u003cdiv style={{marginTop:65,display:'flex',gap:28}}\u003e\u003cdiv style={{flex:1,padding:40,borderRadius:'var(--osd-radius)',border:'2px solid var(--osd-accent)'}}\u003e\u003cdiv style={{fontSize:28,color:'var(--osd-accent)',fontWeight:700}}\u003e反駁一\u003c/div\u003e\u003cp style={{fontSize:37,lineHeight:1.45,marginBottom:0}}\u003e價值本來就有社會來源。難道要從內心憑空長出來，才算真正屬於我？\u003c/p\u003e\u003c/div\u003e\u003cdiv style={{flex:1,padding:40,borderRadius:'var(--osd-radius)',border:'2px solid var(--osd-accent)'}}\u003e\u003cdiv style={{fontSize:28,color:'var(--osd-accent)',fontWeight:700}}\u003e反駁二\u003c/div\u003e\u003cp style={{fontSize:37,lineHeight:1.45,marginBottom:0}}\u003e如果我自願使用、而且確實變好了，怎麼會損害自主？\u003c/p\u003e\u003c/div\u003e\u003c/div\u003e\u003cp style={{fontSize:30,lineHeight:1.45,margin:'48px 0 0',opacity:.73}}\u003e提醒：Nguyen 並沒有主張「所有指標都是壓迫工具」。不要把討論帶成反 KPI 大會。\u003c/p\u003e\u003c/div\u003e); }","createdAt":1789105965351,"id":"715bda337ff019e6554e737b","itemType":"SLIDE","name":"15｜兩個值得反駁的問題","parents":{"3ba9de908281b7d5c34c4c4b":1789103171112},"sourceItemId":"db56fb3d2ad9e0c5db7e4a73","speakerNotes":"鼓勵真正的反方。第一題逼出社會塑造與操控的差別；第二題逼出一次性同意與持續自主的差別。","updatedAt":1789105965351,"updatedBy":{"userId":"2e84aab5-d898-4d2f-8d2a-","userName":"許育慈"},"version":1},{"content":"export default function Slide() { return (\u003cdiv style={{width:'100%',height:'100%',boxSizing:'border-box',padding:125,display:'flex',flexDirection:'column',justifyContent:'center',background:'var(--osd-bg)',color:'var(--osd-text)',fontFamily:'var(--osd-font-body)'}}\u003e\u003cdiv style={{fontSize:27,color:'var(--osd-accent)',fontWeight:700,letterSpacing:3,marginBottom:18}}\u003e02｜制度層\u003c/div\u003e\u003ch1 style={{fontFamily:'var(--osd-font-display)',fontSize:78,lineHeight:1.15,margin:0}}\u003e可列點的動作，慢慢取代了\u003cbr/\u003e原本令人著迷的事。\u003c/h1\u003e\u003cdiv style={{display:'flex',gap:28,marginTop:68}}\u003e\u003cdiv style={{flex:1,padding:37,border:'1px solid rgba(255,255,255,.25)',borderRadius:'var(--osd-radius)'}}\u003e\u003ch2 style={{margin:0,fontSize:39,color:'var(--osd-accent)'}}\u003e競技運動\u003c/h2\u003e\u003cp style={{fontSize:30,lineHeight:1.48,marginBottom:0,opacity:.8}}\u003e滑板、花式滑冰：注意力由風格、流暢與冒險，移向可累積的動作清單。\u003c/p\u003e\u003c/div\u003e\u003cdiv style={{flex:1,padding:37,border:'1px solid rgba(255,255,255,.25)',borderRadius:'var(--osd-radius)'}}\u003e\u003ch2 style={{margin:0,fontSize:39,color:'var(--osd-accent)'}}\u003e學校評量\u003c/h2\u003e\u003cp style={{fontSize:30,lineHeight:1.48,marginBottom:0,opacity:.8}}\u003e成績與評鑑揭露一部分，也遮蔽更多；最後，拿分本身成了學習的目標。\u003c/p\u003e\u003c/div\u003e\u003c/div\u003e\u003cp style={{fontSize:33,marginTop:52,opacity:.72}}\u003e不是因為分數「不真實」；而是因為它真實得太窄。\u003c/p\u003e\u003c/div\u003e); }","createdAt":1789105965351,"id":"db451d35b9ac84d9b8d6be10","itemType":"SLIDE","name":"09｜制度層：計分遮蔽了什麼","parents":{"3ba9de908281b7d5c34c4c4b":1789103170512},"sourceItemId":"dbe51ed790c706e163f0c598","speakerNotes":"把計分理解成注意力裝置：它把某些面向照得極亮，也讓其他面向變得難以看見。","updatedAt":1789105965351,"updatedBy":{"userId":"2e84aab5-d898-4d2f-8d2a-","userName":"許育慈"},"version":1},{"content":"export default function Slide() { return (\u003cdiv style={{width:'100%',height:'100%',boxSizing:'border-box',padding:'110px 135px',display:'flex',flexDirection:'column',justifyContent:'center',background:'var(--osd-bg)',color:'var(--osd-text)',fontFamily:'var(--osd-font-body)'}}\u003e\u003cdiv style={{fontSize:28,color:'var(--osd-accent)',fontWeight:700,letterSpacing:3,marginBottom:22}}\u003e一個實作性的出口\u003c/div\u003e\u003ch1 style={{fontFamily:'var(--osd-font-display)',fontSize:76,lineHeight:1.12,margin:'0 0 60px'}}\u003e下次看到一個分數，先問三件事\u003c/h1\u003e\u003cdiv style={{display:'flex',flexDirection:'column',gap:25}}\u003e\u003cdiv style={{display:'flex',gap:30,alignItems:'center',fontSize:39,lineHeight:1.3}}\u003e\u003cspan style={{fontFamily:'var(--osd-font-display)',fontSize:70,color:'var(--osd-accent)'}}\u003e01\u003c/span\u003e\u003cspan\u003e這個指標原本要代理什麼？它代理得好嗎？\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/div\u003e\u003cdiv style={{display:'flex',gap:30,alignItems:'center',fontSize:39,lineHeight:1.3}}\u003e\u003cspan style={{fontFamily:'var(--osd-font-display)',fontSize:70,color:'var(--osd-accent)'}}\u003e02\u003c/span\u003e\u003cspan\u003e我還關得掉、換得掉，或暫時不用它嗎？\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/div\u003e\u003cdiv style={{display:'flex',gap:30,alignItems:'center',fontSize:39,lineHeight:1.3}}\u003e\u003cspan style={{fontFamily:'var(--osd-font-display)',fontSize:70,color:'var(--osd-accent)'}}\u003e03\u003c/span\u003e\u003cspan\u003e如果分數消失，我還會做這件事嗎？\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/div\u003e\u003c/div\u003e\u003c/div\u003e); }","createdAt":1789105965351,"id":"8b960657a339d56e568a982b","itemType":"SLIDE","name":"16｜三個帶回去的問題","parents":{"3ba9de908281b7d5c34c4c4b":1789103171212},"sourceItemId":"e0065e52b4dae90c11ec55e5","speakerNotes":"這不是戒斷清單，而是重新獲得距離感的三個問題。最後一題特別強：它不要求答案一定是「會」，而是讓人看見自己的答案。","updatedAt":1789105965351,"updatedBy":{"userId":"2e84aab5-d898-4d2f-8d2a-","userName":"許育慈"},"version":1},{"content":"export default function Slide() { return (\u003cdiv style={{width:'100%',height:'100%',boxSizing:'border-box',padding:130,display:'flex',flexDirection:'column',justifyContent:'center',background:'var(--osd-accent)',color:'#141414',fontFamily:'var(--osd-font-body)'}}\u003e\u003cdiv style={{fontSize:29,fontWeight:700,letterSpacing:4,opacity:.72}}\u003e全場高點\u003c/div\u003e\u003ch1 style={{fontFamily:'var(--osd-font-display)',fontSize:110,lineHeight:1.08,margin:'35px 0 60px',maxWidth:1500}}\u003e你不是被騙進去的，\u003cbr/\u003e你是自己走進去的。\u003c/h1\u003e\u003cp style={{fontSize:40,lineHeight:1.5,maxWidth:1450,margin:0}}\u003e我們買 Fitbit、打開 Duolingo，往往正是因為知道點數、等級與連勝會推著自己前進。這是一種\u003cspan style={{fontWeight:800}}\u003e主動求捕獲\u003c/span\u003e：用外部的清晰，對抗自己的意志薄弱。\u003c/p\u003e\u003c/div\u003e); }","createdAt":1789105965351,"id":"f03e37cf15b2228fecd34f30","itemType":"SLIDE","name":"13｜最難的一刀","parents":{"3ba9de908281b7d5c34c4c4b":1789103170912},"sourceItemId":"ebc078dab4fb5918a326fbfd","speakerNotes":"停頓後再講。這頁要讓聽眾理解：被捕獲不是因為我們愚蠢或被動；它常常是明智、有效、甚至被自己選擇的策略。","updatedAt":1789105965351,"updatedBy":{"userId":"2e84aab5-d898-4d2f-8d2a-","userName":"許育慈"},"version":1}]}